WomenTech Global Conference Keynote from Sharon Mandell
How to Achieve Better Business Outcomes by Creating an Inclusive Workplace
This is a replay of a keynote given by Sharon Mandell, SVP and CIO of Juniper Networks, during the WomenTech Global Conference from June 7 - 10, 2022.
In this session Sharon addresses the challenges and opportunities she sees for companies to use this unique time to redesign their approach to diverse hiring. As a CIO at a global tech company, she will share her perspective on the business benefits of an inclusive workforce.
You’ll learn
What COVID-19 did the women’s participation in the workforce
The challenges of the Great Resignation
Who is this for?
Host
Transcript
0:01 [Music]
0:05 um i remember when i was first starting
0:08 out
0:08 in technology uh at the early part of my
0:11 career and and finding other female
0:14 peers and mentors at that time was a
0:16 challenge and maybe older than many of
0:18 you
0:18 there were a few female tech leaders i
0:21 encountered as a student i i had the
0:23 pleasure of meeting grace hopper and
0:26 and adele goldberg who
0:29 was very a very prominent technologist
0:31 at the time
0:32 um but in general as i as i finished
0:35 school and kind of went out into the
0:36 workplace i i had to look for women who
0:39 were successful in other less technical
0:42 fields to connect with and look up to
0:44 um so when i was in the media industry
0:46 for example it was the the female
0:49 publishers of newspapers or gm's of our
0:52 tv stations or our marketing executives
0:55 and it wasn't until i moved to
0:56 california in the early 2000s that and i
0:59 just think it's because there was a
1:00 greater percentage of tech out here um i
1:03 saw more i found more women peers and
1:06 positions of a cto and cio
1:10 but even though that was the case a wide
1:13 gender gap persisted in the technology
1:15 teams that i managed and that i saw in
1:17 other companies and the reality is that
1:20 sustaining a pipeline of strong
1:21 technical women remains a persistent
1:24 challenge to this day and i feel it's
1:26 only been exacerbated by the ongoing
1:28 pandemic
1:30 and while neural activities have have
1:32 started to resume in many parts of the
1:34 world
1:35 covid19 has had a significant impact on
1:38 women's participation in the workforce
1:40 um
1:42 setting back years of progress that had
1:44 been had been made on this front and i
1:46 think that the the scenario is
1:48 especially secure acute in technology
1:52 which has chronically suffered this this
1:54 dearth of female and diverse
1:56 underrepresented talent at all ranks you
1:58 know i look at every challenge as an
2:00 opportunity and um
2:03 and i think that uh
2:04 you know if if if we don't change
2:07 anything nothing changes right so
2:09 there's a very there's a famous quote if
2:11 nothing changes nothing changes or
2:13 i i don't know if it was churchill who
2:15 said you know if you keep doing the same
2:17 things and expect something different on
2:19 the other side then you're you're kind
2:20 of fooling yourself i think as we come
2:23 out of this period uh it's up to us to
2:26 to change the narrative this time
2:28 presents an opportunity to re-level the
2:30 playing field for women and
2:32 underrepresented people
2:33 in tech
2:34 who face bias in the workforce so you
2:38 know there was a study done last fall
2:40 and something like 38
2:42 of women in tech said they were thinking
2:44 of leaving their careers and according
2:46 to a study from the kapoor center of
2:49 women of color and computing
2:51 collaborative
2:53 women of color felt that even
2:55 more so than than white women
2:59 for seeing themselves having a long-term
3:01 future there and i as the cio of a
3:04 global tech company i just find this
3:06 unacceptable unacceptable so
3:09 i'm advocating for a new movement that i
3:11 call the great redesign
3:13 instead of the great resignation or the
3:15 great renegotiation um and i think we
3:18 need to like really look closely at our
3:20 hiring practices and our cultural
3:22 practices in our company to build a
3:24 better place let's talk about um
3:27 recruiting the diverse talent problem i
3:30 think too often is placed on the
3:31 shoulders of hr
3:33 um that it's you know up to them to
3:35 build the pipeline and the problem will
3:37 be solved and quite frankly it's it's
3:39 not that simple um i think the c-suite
3:42 senior leadership and all hiring
3:44 managers have to be engaged in this
3:46 process
3:47 male or female to make sure that we get
3:50 out of our comfort zone and and and not
3:54 do what we tend to do in tech which is
3:57 we have a gap and a hole
3:59 and we go to
4:01 um the first candidate that we see has
4:03 the skill set that that we're looking
4:05 for instead of just going to the obvious
4:08 you know very broad
4:09 tech hiring places you know linkedin
4:12 dice
4:13 you know these generic things i think we
4:15 have to start to put ourselves but
4:17 there's also groups
4:18 like women tech network latinas in tech
4:21 tech ladies black girls who code women
4:24 in cybersecurity anitab.org
4:27 we have to go out and and be where
4:29 people are coming instead of expecting
4:31 the people to show up and land on our
4:33 doorstep then it's not just as i said
4:36 getting that pipeline but you have to
4:37 look at every phase of the hiring
4:39 process
4:40 so
4:41 um you know working with your hr
4:43 business partners take a look at every
4:45 job description first and make sure
4:48 that we're not
4:49 subtly um
4:52 weeding people out by the language that
4:53 we use um or creating job descriptions
4:57 that may
4:58 you know very much focus on skill skills
5:01 skill skill skills rather than talent
5:03 and potential then you know really look
5:06 at your process of who's doing the
5:08 interviewing
5:09 and that's on two fronts right so
5:11 obviously you want a diverse
5:15 group or pool of interviewers so that
5:19 unintended vitas is potentially weeded
5:21 out of the process but you also want to
5:24 look like a place that people come and
5:26 so you want representation also as part
5:29 of your value proposition because when
5:31 people look at you
5:33 hopefully they're going to think well
5:34 that's a place that is diverse and that
5:36 is where i'm going to work to me that's
5:38 that's very important and since changing
5:40 that we've seen
5:42 uh a shift in in the balance of hires um
5:46 at which is now very proportional to the
5:48 pipeline and we're going back to to work
5:50 on the pipeline problem um you have to
5:53 think of inclusivity beyond day one
5:55 right it's not just employee orientation
5:58 but it's all of the ongoing activities
6:00 um that you're going to do to create a
6:03 culture of openness and being responsive
6:06 to when you see things not working
6:08 people being comfortable uh with with
6:11 raising issues and then your leadership
6:14 teams being open to fixing it we have to
6:17 have a sense of belonging and give
6:19 diverse hires the growth potential they
6:21 need and the opportunities
6:24 the same way white men have historically
6:26 received them and it need to do things
6:29 very explicitly to make sure that nobody
6:31 is sitting on the sidelines and that
6:34 underrepresented groups are getting a
6:35 voice during meetings and the decision
6:38 making process we are in technology so
6:41 i always say use the data so
6:44 in the same way as you're looking
6:46 through every step of the pipeline and
6:49 understanding maybe where you have your
6:51 drop-off of of of losing candidates in
6:54 the pipeline
6:56 to help guide your actions it's also the
6:58 same for that ongoing
7:00 nurturing and management of the career
7:02 path once somebody has arrived so you
7:05 know really every time you do a cycle
7:08 look at where the promotions are going
7:09 and if the math isn't working
7:12 you have to ask questions
7:14 and you have to be prepared to talk
7:16 about the people who say when you're
7:19 looking to build a diverse workforce you
7:20 may be discriminating against others but
7:23 you have to take these conscious steps
7:25 to change it also look at your pay data
7:27 often you'll find disparities with women
7:30 and men and um and underrepresented
7:33 groups
7:34 that within the same salary band they're
7:37 not positioned equally my suspicion is
7:39 this happens probably because women in
7:42 underrepresented groups when they come
7:44 to the job the first time are less
7:46 comfortable advocating for themselves
7:49 and of course the way the salary
7:51 negotiation process happens
7:54 you know if people don't ask for what
7:56 they can get or aren't comfortable
7:58 arguing for it then they're going to
8:00 start out at a lower place and that
8:01 comes with that'll continue with them if
8:04 the management leadership teams
8:06 don't look at this data and make
8:07 conscious changes so i literally just
8:10 went through this last week as we did
8:13 our process our annual process
8:15 i held back money from my team so that i
8:18 could make corrections when i saw these
8:21 gaps that we needed to make sure aren't
8:23 persistent
8:25 and lastly we may have to be more
8:26 flexible on
8:28 on where and how people get their work
8:31 done many of us geographically dispersed
8:34 but sometimes uh 50 of your company may
8:37 50 of your team may land in a country
8:40 that perhaps doesn't have the same
8:42 um
8:44 the same opportunities for women the
8:46 same uh
8:47 attitude toward diversity that
8:50 you know it changes country to country
8:51 there may even be legal barriers you
8:53 know one of two things what are the
8:55 actions you're going to take to
8:56 compensate for that and they have to be
8:58 very thoughtful and very explicit
9:01 in terms of enabling those people to
9:03 work and not be penalized for not doing
9:06 it exactly the way somebody who showed
9:08 up in the office always did or perhaps
9:11 you have to start to think about diver
9:13 diversifying those geographic locations
9:15 um in order to overcome that next is
9:19 kind of talking about you know how do we
9:21 create the work environment that we need
9:23 once people are hired and are in our
9:26 companies again it all starts from the
9:28 top so senior leaders i hope you're
9:30 listening you know we're the ones
9:32 responsible for creating the work
9:34 environments that drive this kind of
9:35 change i'm talking about
9:37 um
9:38 some things that we do are you know
9:41 offer multiple forums for candid
9:43 conversations and professional growth
9:46 you need to bolster your your de and i
9:48 approach to support
9:50 employees you know all the time not just
9:53 during these kind of key cycles for
9:55 example juniper networks invest in
9:57 programs that help women and people of
9:59 color build networks of support and
10:01 speak within groups without worrying
10:03 about how others who don't look like or
10:06 operate like them perceive them
10:08 we have special training groups for them
10:11 we have
10:12 leadership and development focus groups
10:14 that we run throughout the company
10:16 so yes so people are are very very
10:18 candid in the environments and and when
10:20 we've been working in roles for for a
10:22 long time i think many of us think we've
10:25 seen all the problems and we understand
10:27 what all the challenges are
10:29 but
10:30 the reality is it evolves and it changes
10:32 over time and so
10:34 while we will hear many of those things
10:37 that we expect from these focus groups
10:39 i'm i'm constantly
10:41 learning about new ones that that we
10:43 have to take on and we have to address
10:44 through some of these programs
10:47 obviously visibility during the pandemic
10:50 has been a problem
10:52 we have to become much more
10:55 explicit about making sure
10:58 that everybody is seeing and uh i joined
11:01 my company during the pandemic so i've
11:04 had to take on many steps to make sure
11:06 that the people at levels that don't
11:09 immediately report to me get to see
11:12 me and and set the tone and set the
11:14 values so it's something that i don't
11:17 think is going to go away because the
11:19 hybrid the world is more likely to be
11:21 hybrid than go back to what we had
11:22 before
11:23 um and so
11:25 you can assume that you can do
11:27 everything by walking around but you you
11:29 must actually set time so one of the
11:32 things i've done is i have these
11:34 sessions i call them schmoozing with
11:36 sharon
11:38 we
11:39 don't allow kind of the the direct
11:42 reports are my senior management it just
11:44 becomes an open forum
11:45 for individuals at different levels to
11:48 be able to talk and get to know me and
11:50 ask their questions and tell me what's
11:52 going on without any fear of you know
11:55 who's gonna who's gonna hear about it um
11:58 there's many other techniques people
11:59 have done um to try to create that
12:02 environment where people feel more
12:04 comfortable and included so that you're
12:06 you're not leaving people sitting on the
12:07 sidelines
12:09 women in the tech industry haven't
12:11 always had uh the same management
12:14 support and sponsorship and mentorship
12:16 support that men have
12:18 so we need to make sure that as those
12:21 things are happening they're getting
12:22 distributed evenly and fairly and we
12:25 have to we have to go out and maybe
12:28 advocate to find sponsors and mentors
12:30 for people um but that maybe it doesn't
12:33 even happen inside your organization but
12:35 some other part of the organization that
12:37 can give them
12:38 those opportunities and help them see
12:40 where they need to grow and develop
12:44 the
12:46 lack of management support lack of
12:48 opportunity and work-life balance are
12:52 main reasons for departures for women in
12:54 stem careers and again we see them leave
12:57 within the first few years um because i
13:00 think without that support
13:02 you know they've heard people have heard
13:04 about you know the great that we get
13:06 paid well in our field um that we solve
13:08 challenging problems but
13:11 if the leadership teams and the
13:12 management aren't really making sure
13:14 that that opportunity
13:16 is evenly distributed then
13:19 um and fairly distributed then what
13:21 happens is it only feels that way for
13:23 some people and and they need to move on
13:26 so again it requires the onus is on us
13:29 as leaders and not at the people at the
13:32 lower levels to always be raising their
13:34 hands
13:35 the other thing is you know for those
13:37 reasons
13:40 i really try to get out and spend time
13:45 in both stem and i say steam
13:47 organizations
13:49 i don't think that all of the tech
13:52 leaders are going to come out of college
13:54 with computer science degrees i think
13:56 that again we need to be hiring
13:59 for capability we're all going to
14:02 re-skill i have re-skilled over and over
14:05 and over again over the course of my
14:06 career
14:08 that's going to happen for anyone who's
14:10 in technology and so we can't assume
14:12 that if you didn't graduate with a
14:14 computer science degree you don't have
14:15 any future here in tech
14:17 um and so we need to go out to those
14:20 places and and show
14:22 uh women what's possible
14:24 and
14:25 tell them about the great work that's
14:27 here
14:28 so you know i do that through
14:31 the organizations the education and the
14:33 arts boards and i actually now teach uh
14:36 as part of my opportunity to because
14:39 when i go into a classroom it's often
14:40 more than
14:41 um more than half women um and i want
14:45 them to see somebody who's who's getting
14:47 great work and having a great career um
14:50 and so i can't scale that on my own but
14:52 if we are all out engaging with that uh
14:56 we can really show and change that this
14:58 is an
14:59 inclusive place um juniper specifically
15:02 has some other things to encourage women
15:04 for careers and stamps so
15:06 uh we
15:08 we do this through mentorship internship
15:11 and speaking engagements
15:13 like this one here to try to help people
15:15 understand what's possible
15:17 we also um
15:19 financially support organizations so
15:21 we're lucky we have a philanthropic arm
15:24 and we will invest in that
15:27 but many companies may not have that but
15:29 they may have donor matching problem
15:31 donor matching programs so that
15:34 employees can support organizations
15:37 again like jackie's that that are are
15:39 trying to make it possible for for women
15:42 to feel as comfortable and as empowered
15:45 as they grow up uh as technologists
15:49 we work through colleges
15:51 and we have our education services offer
15:55 certifications so if your company has a
15:57 product and
15:59 you can go help deliver that training
16:01 and get other women
16:03 comfortable with technology it's another
16:05 way to kind of bring more people into
16:07 the field and then as i said once they
16:10 have the positions
16:12 all of the things we discussed earlier
16:14 sponsorship mentorship um
16:16 managing that equal pay
16:18 um and and doing that pay equity
16:21 analysis making sure the opportunities
16:23 exist for development and advancement
16:25 are there
16:26 and then the other thing we really have
16:29 to do
16:29 again particularly in this this
16:32 you know this time of the pandemic is
16:34 women still shoulder
16:36 much of the
16:38 you know
16:38 workload around children when they're
16:40 home and during the pandemic i think
16:43 that probably became untenable from for
16:45 many many people
16:47 um
16:48 you know having to try to do the job and
16:50 and be around at all the exact same
16:53 hours while also trying to raise their
16:55 kids uh through school my daughter was
16:57 long graduated by it by the time it
17:00 happened but um
17:01 i think it was very very tough on them
17:03 so you know i i really listen for
17:06 language around the company when i hear
17:08 something like
17:09 oh you know that person was doing great
17:11 and in the past year or so i've seen
17:13 this other person surpass them and i and
17:15 i ask okay well does that person have
17:17 kids you know you really
17:19 you know when you hear something you
17:21 know how people say if you see something
17:23 say something uh you know in a situation
17:26 at you know an airport or something like
17:28 that i think we have to do that
17:30 ourselves at work when we hear things we
17:32 really have to hold our our peers and
17:35 others around us
17:37 accountable and sorry about the
17:38 shuffling um so that that they are um
17:42 that they're aware that again some
17:45 things that they may be doing or saying
17:47 unintentionally
17:48 are are held holding our colleagues who
17:51 are you know maybe working double time
17:53 just to stay in the field
17:55 um holding them behind and then to the
17:58 degree women leave the workforce
18:00 and in tech it's really it's really
18:02 really challenging to come back and the
18:05 longer they stay away um the harder it
18:07 is to re-enter so again supporting
18:09 organizations and working with
18:11 organizations that kind of help
18:14 get those people leveled up and and back
18:17 into the workforce and creating
18:19 opportunities for them
18:21 um extremely extremely important and you
18:24 know we all do this right because it's
18:26 the right thing to do we all believe
18:28 it's our right and um to
18:32 to have the same opportunities um that
18:35 other classes of of of people have but
18:38 it's also the thing that makes good
18:40 business sense so
18:43 you know the need for diversity is clear
18:46 more diversity equals more innovation
18:48 and more innovation leads to more market
18:50 growth
18:52 the world economic forum in 2020
18:55 highlighted that companies that lead in
18:57 the dei space
19:00 they better perform on any number of
19:02 metrics that includes profitability
19:05 innovation
19:06 decision making
19:08 and um employee engagement and keeping
19:11 our workforce uh that we've invested so
19:14 much in versus
19:16 um having the churn and having to spend
19:19 the money on recruiting and
19:22 uh
19:23 bringing somebody up to speed in the new
19:25 organization making them part of the
19:26 culture um obviously that will lead to
19:29 better economic results if we can keep
19:31 the great people we have rather than
19:33 having them
19:34 churn out because they don't feel
19:36 comfortable from a profitability
19:38 standpoint it's 26 to 25 to 36 percent
19:42 more profitable
19:44 um 20
19:46 um higher innovation and commence
19:48 commensurate innovation revenues uh that
19:52 go along with this and up to a 30
19:54 percent greater ability to to recognize
19:58 um
19:59 and and uh mitigate business risk uh
20:03 come with this these programs mckinsey
20:06 itself did a a a another report
20:11 showing many of the same things that
20:13 inclusive companies way outperformed
20:15 those who aren't and they broke the
20:17 companies into cohorts those who had 30
20:20 percent or more
20:22 executive women 10 to 30 percent
20:28 women executives and then less than 10
20:31 percent
20:32 and not only did they show that there
20:35 was a an increase in in profitability
20:39 but that um the gap grew wider and wider
20:43 over time between these different
20:44 cohorts and yet despite that data
20:49 um
20:50 a third of the companies that were part
20:51 of that survey had no women executives
20:54 yet at the leadership level so you know
20:57 the the data is clear and it and it
21:00 really shows that by including us we we
21:03 drive better business outcomes um
21:06 another study showed similar results
21:09 based on data with women and
21:12 underrepresented minorities uh on board
21:15 of directors
21:16 um and so the greater proportionality so
21:19 it's not just adding it's not good
21:22 enough to just add women to boards or
21:24 add underrepresented minorities to the
21:26 boards you have to
21:27 increase the proportionality of the
21:29 board otherwise you're just kind of
21:32 sliding things over a bit
21:34 but you get return on assets that are 8
21:37 to 13 percent basis points higher for
21:40 companies that have that diversity so
21:43 um it isn't just the right thing to do
21:45 but it's the um
21:48 it it makes good business sense and and
21:50 that's why we really have to take on
21:52 this great redesign
21:54 so
21:55 um
21:56 in conclusion uh you know the while
22:00 we're we're trying to you know be fair
22:03 right
22:04 um you know moral
22:06 use our full human capital um
22:10 it also drives the results our companies
22:12 want to have
22:14 um it's not something that's easy or
22:16 trivial it's going to take
22:18 real incremental
22:20 conscious intentional hard work
22:23 but the results are worth it
22:25 and it's going to be a mix of very
22:27 tactical and strategic work that we have
22:29 to do
22:31 but all of the change and uncertainty
22:33 going on now
22:35 this is the time where real leaders
22:37 distinguish themselves it's not when
22:39 everything's going great and rising
22:41 tides are raising all boats but it's in
22:43 these times of challenge and uncertainty
22:45 and change
22:47 from external factors that allow us to
22:50 go drive change and really capitalize on
22:52 that and so my you know we need to be
22:56 conscious about that and then my advice
22:58 to each one of you as individuals is to
23:01 you know work hard play hard
23:04 do what you love
23:05 uh what you're passionate about and then
23:08 find those who recognize that in you
23:11 so you can have that impact and and make
23:13 it exponential
23:14 [Music]